JUAN DE ZURBARÁN (LLERENA 1620-1649 SEVILLE)
JUAN DE ZURBARÁN (LLERENA 1620-1649 SEVILLE)
JUAN DE ZURBARÁN (LLERENA 1620-1649 SEVILLE)
JUAN DE ZURBARÁN (LLERENA 1620-1649 SEVILLE)
3 More
PROPERTY FROM AN IMPORTANT EUROPEAN FAMILY COLLECTION
ORAZIO GENTILESCHI (PISA 1563-1639 LONDON)

Noli me tangere

Details
ORAZIO GENTILESCHI (PISA 1563-1639 LONDON)
Noli me tangere
oil on canvas, unlined
48 x 67 ¼ in. (121.7 x 170.8 cm.)
Provenance
In a noble European collection since at least the 19th century, and probably by the second quarter of the 17th century.

Brought to you by

Maja Markovic
Maja Markovic Director, Head of Evening Sale

Lot Essay

This newly discovered work is an important addition to the œuvre of the Tuscan-born baroque painter Orazio Gentileschi. Painted in Rome during the years when the revolutionary impact of Caravaggio’s art was being felt most keenly, it can be dated to the opening years of the seventeenth century, probably circa 1600-05.

Noli me tangere is precisely the sort of picture that the young Artemisia Gentileschi, then beginning to assist in her father’s workshop, would have known at first hand. Indeed, the Magdalen possesses a truthfulness and unaffected naturalism that recall Artemisia’s own heroines. The forceful lighting and heightened naturalism reveal the direct influence of Caravaggio, with whom Orazio was closely associated at this time. The two artists were evidently acquainted: during the 1603 libel trial brought by Giovanni Baglione, Orazio testified that, although he had not spoken to Caravaggio for several months, the latter had recently returned props borrowed for his paintings, namely a Capuchin habit and a pair of wings (see S. Macioce, Michelangelo Merisi da Caravaggio. Fonti e Documenti 1532-1574, Rome, 2003, p. 130). Orazio’s Caravaggesque phase was, however, relatively short-lived. In 1621, he was invited to Genoa by the nobleman Giovan Antonio Sauli and subsequently worked in Turin, Paris and London, where he entered the service of King Charles I and Queen Henrietta Maria. During these years he adopted a more elegant and courtly style, characterised by a richer and more varied colour palette.

The subject is taken from the New Testament (John 20:14-18) and depicts Christ after the Resurrection appearing to his grieving follower Mary Magdalene. On recognising him, she reaches out to touch him, whereupon Christ says ‘Touch me not; for I am not yet ascended to my Father’ (the title ‘noli me tangere’ derives from a Latin translation of Christ’s words, ‘do not touch me’). Widely popular during the Renaissance, with famous painted examples by Titian (London, National Gallery) and Correggio (Madrid, Museo Nacional del Prado), the subject is not often found in early seventeenth-century painting. Here, Christ’s serene expression contrasts with the Magdalene’s emotional turmoil, while his raised hand displays the wound of the Crucifixion. The episode centres on the poignant exchange between Christ and the Magdalene, the emotional charge and dramatic tension of their not quite touching being ideally suited to a Caravaggesque interpretation.

According to the Gospel, the scene took place on the morning of Easter Sunday in a garden near the site of Christ’s tomb. Rather than setting his figures in a lush, verdant landscape, Orazio places them before a wall of exposed brick and crumbling plaster, a motif that recurs in other works, including the Rest on the Flight into Egypt (c. 1620; Birmingham Museums) and the Madonna and Child in a Landscape (c. 1621-2; Stamford, Burghley House). The crumbling masonry carries theological significance for it symbolises the old order giving way to the new, as represented by Christ’s Resurrection and the promise of spiritual renewal. A halo glows around Christ’s head, while the wooden pole resting in the crook of his arm is intended as a gardener’s spade or hoe, alluding to the fact that the Magdalene first mistook him for a gardener. Kneeling at Christ’s feet, she reaches towards him as he raises his right hand in a gesture of blessing. Her outstretched arms and submissive pose indicate that this is the moment of recognition: Orazio captures the pivotal moment of revelation, just as Caravaggio did in his Supper at Emmaus (1601; London, National Gallery) when the disciples recognise the resurrected Christ. Here, too, the strong directional lighting lends the scene a theatrical quality, focusing attention on the protagonists and heightening the drama of their encounter.

The painting and its commission are unrecorded in the sources, and its early history remains unknown. Given its scale and format, which appears to have survived largely intact (apart from a slight reduction at the right edge), it seems likely that the picture was commissioned by a private client to hang in their palazzo. Stylistic considerations and the treatment of the figures suggest a date of circa 1600-05. The physiognomy of the young, beardless Christ, with his long straight nose, almond-shaped eyes and delicate brows, finds its closest counterparts in Orazio’s recently discovered Christ Blessing (1600-05; Private collection; fig. 1; see S. Causa, in Orazio Gentileschi. Un pittore in viaggio, exhibition catalogue, Turin, 2025, pp. 82, 88-9, no. I.2, illustrated in colour) and in the figure of Christ in his Assumption altarpiece (c. 1605; Turin, Palazzo Madama – Musei Civico d’Arte Antica; see C. Arnaldi di Balme, in ibid., pp. 83, 89-90, no. I.3, illustrated in colour). The heavy draperies and figure types are also reminiscent of those in the Baptism of Christ altarpiece in Santa Maria della Pace, Rome (1607). The closest parallel, however, is Orazio’s Way to Calvary (c. 1605-07; Vienna, Kunsthistorisches Museum; fig. 2), not only in its tightly cropped composition and dramatic tension but also in the striking correspondence between the figure of the Magdalene here and that of Veronica in the Vienna picture.

We are grateful to the following scholars for endorsing the attribution to Orazio Gentileschi upon firsthand inspection: Keith Christiansen, who has qualified his opinion by stating that, in its present unrestored state, he is inclined to accept it; and Yuri Primarosa and Maria Cristina Terzaghi, who have accepted the attribution unequivocally. We also wish to thank Tommaso Borgogelli, Patrizia Cavazzini and Gianni Papi for endorsing the attribution to Orazio on the basis of photographs.

More from Old Masters Evening Sale

View All
View All