3 More
PROPERTY FROM THE ESTATE OF AMBASSADOR J. WILLIAM MIDDENDORF II, RHODE ISLAND
MASTER OF THE DINKELSBÜHL ALTAR (ACTIVE SWABIA AND FRANCONIA, LATE 15TH CENTURY-EARLY 16TH CENTURY)

The Massacre of the Innocents

Details
MASTER OF THE DINKELSBÜHL ALTAR (ACTIVE SWABIA AND FRANCONIA, LATE 15TH CENTURY-EARLY 16TH CENTURY)
The Massacre of the Innocents
oil and gold on panel
29 3⁄8 x 32 1⁄8 in. (74.7 x 81.7 cm.)
Provenance
(Possibly) Commissioned by the Berlin family for the parish church of Saint George, Dinkelsbühl, circa 1500.
Private collection, Vienna.
Anonymous sale; Dorotheum, Vienna, 22 September 1964, lot 66, as ‘the Meister des Münchener Drachenkampfes’, circa 1460-70.
Anonymous sale [Property from a European Private Collection]; Christie's, New York, 30 October 2018, lot 18, where acquired.
Literature
A. Stange, Kritisches Verzeichnis der deutschen Tafelbilder vor Dürer, Munich, 1967, II, p. 59, no. 218, as 'the Meister des Münchener Drachenkampfes'.
O. Benesch, 'Zur österreichischen Handzeichnung der Gothik und Renaissance,' Collected Writings. Volume III. German and Austrian Art of the 15th and 16th Centuries, E. Benesch, ed., London, 1972, pp. 394 and 450, note 14, pl. 417, as 'Follower of the Schotten Master, circa 1490'.
C. Heck and E. Mœnsch-Scherer, Catalogue général des peintures du Musée d'Unterlinden, Colmar, 1990, no. 519.
C. Heck, 'La Vie du Christ et les Quatorze Intercesseurs sur les volets du retable de Dinkelsbühl', Aus Albrecht Dürers Welt: Festschrift für Fedja Anzelewsky, Turnhout, 2001, pp. 25-31, as 'Middle Rhenish School, circa 1500'.
B. Konrad, A. Stange: Kritisches Verzeichnis mit Abbildungen und Ergänzungen, DVD, 2009, II, no. 218, fig. 1.

Brought to you by

Maja Markovic
Maja Markovic Director, Head of Evening Sale

Lot Essay

This exceptional panel combines the traditions of the fifteenth century with the artistic advances that would reach their apogee in the work of painters such as Albrecht Dürer, Lucas Cranach the Elder and the Holbein family in the sixteenth century. The picture has been associated by Christian Heck with a further three scenes from the Life of Christ, which together can be grouped as the lateral panels of a large retable, and would originally have flanked a sculpted interior (see fig. 1 for a reconstruction of the altarpiece; C. Heck, op. cit., 2001). These panels, showing The Marriage at Cana (Colmar, Musée d’Unterlinden), Christ and the Woman taken in Adultery (formerly Philadelphia, Geiger collection) and The Baptism of Christ (present location unknown), all share near-identical dimensions and a consistency of style that convincingly supports their grouping. Heck further associated three panels with the exterior of the altarpiece, showing the Fourteen Holy Helpers (Vierzehn Nothelfer): Saints Leonard, Vitus, Pantaleon and Giles (Frankfurt, Dompfarrhaus); Saints Christopher, Eustace and George (Stuttgart, Staatsgalerie); and Saints Margaret, Catherine and Barbara (Nuremberg, Germanisches Nationalmuseum). The missing outer panel would presumably have shown the remaining four, drawn from Saints Erasmus, Cyriacus, Denis, Blaise and Acacius.

Heck’s reconstruction was supported by careful technical examination of the component panels. The Marriage at Cana and the Stuttgart Saints Christopher, Eustace and George were found to be the two faces of a single panel, divided in the nineteenth century. Further details of the dispersed altarpiece have been proposed by Kurt Löcher, who associated the wings of the altarpiece with a predella panel that has subsequently been attached to a neo-Gothic altarpiece in the parochial church of Saint George in the town of Dinkelsbühl, in Franconia on the Swabian border (K. Löcher, ‘Drei heilige Jungfrauen – von einem Nothelferaltar aus Dinkelsbühl’, Monatsanzeiger: Museen und Ausstellungen in Nürnberg, 208, July 1998, pp. 2-3). The panel, depicting Saint Anne with the Virgin and Child flanked by Saints Lawrence, Leonard, Agatha and Florian and decorated with the emblems of the family who commissioned it, is of comparable dimensions to the wings. Löcher further associates two statues of Saint Agatha and Saint Florian, re-used in another altarpiece in the church, with the retable, arguing that these would originally have come from the centre of the altarpiece.

More from Old Masters Evening Sale

View All
View All