Lot Essay
Rarely did a subject offer Lucas Cranach the Elder a more compelling union of moral gravity and sensual invention than the tragic fate of Lucretia. In his hands, the Roman heroine became one of the most distinctive and enduring figures of the Northern Renaissance, her exemplary sacrifice transformed into an image of extraordinary intimacy and beauty. Painted around 1509-10, this exceptionally refined panel is now recognised as his earliest surviving treatment of the subject (2012 sale catalogue, op. cit, note 4), which he would revisit throughout his long career in a remarkable succession of variations. Among the most accomplished works of his early Wittenberg period, it marks a formative moment in the evolution of his distinctive female types, in which the naturalism and delicacy of his early manner are brought to bear upon a subject whose classical associations offered ample opportunity for sensual display. The resulting image is one of profound ambiguity, in which an act of exemplary virtue is transformed into a scene of intimate and unsettling beauty.
The story of Lucretia, recounted by Livy in his Ab urbe condita (From the Founding of the City; I, 57-59), was among the most celebrated examples of female virtue inherited from antiquity. The wife of the Roman nobleman Lucius Tarquinius Collatinus, Lucretia was raped by Sextus Tarquinius, son of the last king of Rome, Tarquinius Superbus. Having summoned her husband and father, who absolved her of blame and swore to avenge her, she nevertheless took her own life, determined that her fate should never serve as an excuse for another woman’s infidelity. Her death precipitated the uprising that overthrew the Tarquin monarchy and established the Roman Republic, investing her sacrifice with a political significance that extended beyond the preservation of personal and familial honour. Although her suicide presented difficulties for Christian moralists, Lucretia continued to be celebrated as an exemplar of chastity, fidelity and courage, her story finding renewed favour among Renaissance humanists (see J. Follak, Lucretia zwischen positiver und negativer Anthropologie, Konstanz, 2002).
Such examples of classical virtue were particularly familiar at the court of the Electors of Saxony, where Cranach had established himself as court painter to Frederick the Wise in 1505. In his idealised account of Wittenberg, published in 1508, the humanist Andreas Meinhard described the castle as adorned with scenes from ancient history and mythology. Alongside the Labours of Hercules were episodes celebrating Roman courage, including Horatius’s defence of the bridge over the Tiber and Mucius Scaevola’s burning of his own right hand, as well as representations of female modesty and fidelity (M. Evans, ‘“The Italians, who usually pursue fame, proffer their hand to you”: Lucas Cranach and the Art of Humanism’, Cranach, exhibition catalogue, London, 2007, pp. 52-3).
The esteem in which Cranach was already held is evident from a Latin oration delivered by the humanist Christoph Scheurl on 16 December 1508, in which he placed the artist above all his German contemporaries save Albrecht Dürer, acclaiming him as ‘the gifted, quick, consummate painter of the Saxon dukes’, worthy of ‘the first place in painting’. Such was his reputation, Scheurl declared, that ‘the Italians who usually pursue fame, proffer their hand to you, the French greet you as their master’ (H. Lüdecke, ed., Lucas Cranach der Ältere. Der Künstler und seine Zeit, Berlin, 1953, pp. 49-55; translated in Evans, ibid., p. 53). In likening Cranach to the great painters of antiquity, from Apelles to Zeuxis, he invoked only one other living artist, the Bolognese Francesco Francia, whose achievements had been praised by Scheurl’s own teacher, Filippo Beroaldo, in his commentary on Apuleius’s Metamorphoses of 1500.
It was within this humanist milieu that Cranach’s conception of Lucretia took shape, at a moment of considerable experimentation in his art. His journey to the Netherlands in 1508, in the course of which he is likely to have visited Antwerp, has prompted considerable discussion concerning the extent to which Netherlandish painting informed his subsequent work. The emergence of the female half-length figure in his early treatments of Lucretia and Salome has likewise been associated with Netherlandish pictorial conventions, although the originality of his developing artistic language resists any straightforward account of foreign influence (Friedländer and Rosenberg, op. cit., 1978, p. 21; Koepplin and Falk, op. cit., 1976, pp. 660-1). The representation of Lucretia as an intimate, half-length figure was not without precedent in contemporary Italian painting, notably in Francesco Francia’s treatment of the subject of circa 1505-6 (Dresden, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen, Gemäldegalerie), while the sensual framing of the female body by luxuriant fur and flowing hair finds a suggestive parallel in Giorgione’s Laura of 1506 (Vienna, Kunsthistorisches Museum; fig. 1). Although these affinities suggest a broader Italian pictorial context for Cranach’s invention, his familiarity with either painting remains uncertain (Evans, op. cit., p. 53). Whatever the precise sources of his invention, Cranach transformed these conventions into an idiom unmistakably his own, rejecting both the narrative elaboration and the anatomical idealisation preferred by many of his contemporaries in favour of a more intimate, psychologically suggestive image. In both Lucretia and his early representations of Salome, the drama of the subject is distilled into the commanding presence of a richly adorned female figure.
Rather than narrating the circumstances of her death, Cranach isolates the heroine against a dark, unmodulated ground, removing every indication of place and circumstance to concentrate attention upon the figure herself. Dressed in the elaborate fashion of the Saxon court, Lucretia has loosened her white gown to reveal her right breast, its richly embroidered borders and extravagantly puffed sleeves contrasting with the pale softness of her flesh. A deep green mantle envelops her left side, its luxuriant fur lining falling in long, finely articulated strands across her shoulders and lap, while a succession of heavy gold links descends from her neck. The exquisite precision with which Cranach describes these materials, from the delicately threaded pearls of her necklace to the individual curls that escape beneath her narrow headband, is matched by a remarkable tenderness in the modelling of her face. Her softly rounded features, slightly parted lips and steady outward gaze lend her an intimacy at odds with the tragic nature of the subject, while the elaborate arrangement of costume and jewellery both conceals and exposes the body, heightening the sensuality of an image ostensibly devoted to the triumph of chastity.
This conjunction of contemplation and sensuality is fundamental to Cranach’s treatment of Lucretia. Unlike Dürer, whose monumental standing Lucretia of 1518 (Munich, Alte Pinakothek; fig. 2) gives physical expression to the heroine’s fatal resolve, Cranach dispensed with the dramatic action of the suicide, presenting instead a contemplative figure whose direct engagement with the beholder invites reflection upon the meaning of her sacrifice. The Besinnlichkeit, or contemplative quality, of Cranach’s early Lucretias distinguishes them from the more energetic interpretations of the subject by his contemporaries, the violence of death giving way to a state in which its proximity and the sensuality of the female body could coexist (Koepplin and Falk, op. cit., 1976, pp. 660-1). His earliest treatments present the heroine as both ‘life-like and seductive’, possessed of an ‘acute sense of urgency’ about her tragic fate (Ainsworth, op. cit., 2022, p. 90), although in the present picture that urgency is conveyed with remarkable restraint. The dagger has barely penetrated Lucretia’s flesh, and the blood, rather than staining her breast, travels down the polished blade to gather at the guard of its gilded hilt. Executed with extraordinary delicacy, this minute detail establishes the gravity of the action while leaving the figure’s composure undisturbed. The spectator is thus confronted not with the physical horror of suicide but with an image that seems to resist the passage of time, in which beauty and death, innocence and desire are held in precarious equilibrium.
The present composition is closely related to another Lucretia, formerly in the collection of Heinz Kisters, Kreuzlingen, and subsequently in a private collection, which is dated to around 1510-13 (Friedländer and Rosenberg, op. cit., 1978, p. 78, no. 42; fig. 3). The two paintings are of comparable size and share the same essential arrangement, with the heroine presented before a dark ground, enveloped in fur and elaborate contemporary dress, the dagger raised towards her exposed breast. In the Kisters version, however, Lucretia’s hair is gathered up and both breasts are revealed, whereas in the present picture her long, loosely falling curls and the greater concealment afforded by her garments lend the figure a softer, more intimate character. Koepplin considered the Kisters painting to be the earliest surviving treatment of the subject, a dating supported by the existence of a copy bearing the monogram of Cranach’s pupil Hans Döring and the date 1514 (Koepplin and Falk, op. cit., 1976, pp. 661-2, nos. 576 and 578). The subsequent reassessment of the present panel, however, has established its priority, placing it at the beginning of this important sequence of compositions and revealing how fully Cranach had already conceived the essential characteristics of a type that would undergo numerous transformations over the following decades.
The continuing appeal of Cranach’s invention at the Saxon court is evident from a painting of Lucretia that he included among the decorations of the bridal bed of John the Steadfast and Margaret of Anhalt in 1513, described in a contemporary nuptial poem by Philipp Engelbrecht: ‘In the final place is the dishonoured Roman lady. The sword is sprayed with blood, the once starry eyes are half dimmed, Lucretia’s raiment glides from her swelling bosom’ (Lüdecke, op. cit., pp. 56 and 104-5). Cranach’s enduring engagement with the subject is further attested by the electoral accounts, which record two paintings of Lucretia in 1518, while another was presented by the court to Philipp von Solms in 1543 (W. Schade, Die Malerfamilie Cranach, Dresden, 1974, pp. 409 and 440). Yet the appeal of the subject cannot be explained by its moral associations alone, for Cranach’s treatment of Lucretia was equally suited to the tastes of Saxon courtiers who delighted in sensual representations of women. For Cranach, whose fascination with the female figure would become one of the defining features of his art, the classical heroine offered an opportunity to reconcile the exemplary virtues of antiquity with the sensuous pleasures of painting, an apparent contradiction that he made central to his conception of Lucretia.
The painting’s closest stylistic affinities are to be found not so much among Cranach’s later Lucretias, whose increasingly attenuated forms and stylised elegance reflect the development of his mature manner, as among his other female figures of the years around 1509-10. The Venus in the State Hermitage Museum, Saint Petersburg, and the Virgin and Child in the Museo Nacional Thyssen-Bornemisza, Madrid, share the present figure’s softly rounded physiognomy, delicate modelling and exceptionally sensitive treatment of hair, together with the richness of a palette in which luminous flesh is set against deep, saturated colour. Such refinement belongs to a period in which Cranach’s increasingly conscious pursuit of feminine beauty was accompanied by a growing delight in the decorative possibilities of jewellery, brocade and hair, a taste already given remarkable expression in the wings of the Martyrdom of Saint Catherine altarpiece of 1506 (London, The National Gallery; fig. 4), where the ornament is laid in with a fine, pointed brush. The same freedom and immediacy distinguish the Holy Kinship altarpiece of 1509 in Frankfurt, whose rich and abundant brushwork has nothing of the vitreous glossiness of the altarpieces painted shortly after 1510 (Friedländer and Rosenberg, op. cit., 1978, p. 21). The affinities between these sacred, mythological and historical subjects reveal the extent to which Cranach’s ideal of feminine beauty transcended their individual iconographies. Yet there is nothing formulaic in the present figure, whose expression and meticulously observed details retain an immediacy that distinguishes these early works from the more consciously mannered inventions of his later career.
The painting’s exceptionally early date has been further substantiated by technical examination undertaken before its sale in 2012 (op. cit.). The support consists of four narrow boards of limewood joined horizontally, an unusual arrangement associated with the panel-making practices employed during Cranach’s first years at Wittenberg and encountered in the wings of the Martyrdom of Saint Catherine and the Frankfurt Holy Kinship. This method appears to have been largely abandoned by around 1510-11, providing persuasive evidence for the proposed dating of the present work (see G. Heydenreich, Lucas Cranach the Elder: Painting Materials, Techniques and Workshop Practice, Amsterdam, 2007, pp. 57-8). Examination of the margins also revealed that the original framing elements had been nailed to the panel before the application of two successive white grounds, the first, more fluid preparation passing beneath the frame and the second accumulating against it to form a characteristic barbe, traces of which remain visible around the painted surface. Although infrared reflectography revealed no discernible underdrawing, the artist’s creative process is nevertheless apparent in a change to the length and positioning of Lucretia’s left thumb, which was initially conceived smaller and possibly concealed beneath the fur of her mantle. These findings, recorded following the examination of the panel and its preparation by George Bisacca, provide valuable evidence of Cranach’s working methods at this formative stage of his career (op. cit., 2012).
Despite its importance, the present painting remained comparatively little known for much of the twentieth century. Its first published reference appeared in 1932, when a seated Lucretia wearing a fur mantle and with her right shoulder exposed, then known from its appearance on the London art market in 1920, was mentioned in a discussion of a Virgin of Sorrows then in the Birnbaum collection, Amsterdam (Friedländer and Rosenberg, op. cit., 1932, p. 39, under no. 48). The painting was subsequently mentioned as a variant of the Kisters Lucretia in 1976, before being included as an autograph work in the revised catalogue of 1978, where it was dated to circa 1512-14 (Friedländer and Rosenberg, op. cit., 1978, p. 80, no. 55). Following its reappearance and examination in 2011, Werner Schade proposed a date of circa 1509, on the basis of high-resolution photographs and transparencies, while Dieter Koepplin, having examined the painting in person, suggested circa 1510, both recognising it as Cranach’s earliest surviving depiction of Lucretia (op. cit., 2012).
In the present Lucretia, the young court painter had already arrived at a conception of the female figure that was at once intensely individual and capable of almost limitless variation, transforming the moral exemplarity of an ancient heroine into an image whose appeal depended as much upon the delicacy of its execution as upon the ambiguities of its meaning. Yet what distinguishes this earliest treatment from the many that followed is the remarkable restraint with which Cranach achieves that effect. The heroine neither recoils from death nor yields entirely to the sensuality of her presentation; held between the two, she retains a gravity and inwardness that would gradually give way to the more stylised elegance of his mature art. It is in this delicate balance, between the immediacy of a living presence and the stillness of an exemplary image, that the originality of Cranach’s early invention is most fully realised.
The story of Lucretia, recounted by Livy in his Ab urbe condita (From the Founding of the City; I, 57-59), was among the most celebrated examples of female virtue inherited from antiquity. The wife of the Roman nobleman Lucius Tarquinius Collatinus, Lucretia was raped by Sextus Tarquinius, son of the last king of Rome, Tarquinius Superbus. Having summoned her husband and father, who absolved her of blame and swore to avenge her, she nevertheless took her own life, determined that her fate should never serve as an excuse for another woman’s infidelity. Her death precipitated the uprising that overthrew the Tarquin monarchy and established the Roman Republic, investing her sacrifice with a political significance that extended beyond the preservation of personal and familial honour. Although her suicide presented difficulties for Christian moralists, Lucretia continued to be celebrated as an exemplar of chastity, fidelity and courage, her story finding renewed favour among Renaissance humanists (see J. Follak, Lucretia zwischen positiver und negativer Anthropologie, Konstanz, 2002).
Such examples of classical virtue were particularly familiar at the court of the Electors of Saxony, where Cranach had established himself as court painter to Frederick the Wise in 1505. In his idealised account of Wittenberg, published in 1508, the humanist Andreas Meinhard described the castle as adorned with scenes from ancient history and mythology. Alongside the Labours of Hercules were episodes celebrating Roman courage, including Horatius’s defence of the bridge over the Tiber and Mucius Scaevola’s burning of his own right hand, as well as representations of female modesty and fidelity (M. Evans, ‘“The Italians, who usually pursue fame, proffer their hand to you”: Lucas Cranach and the Art of Humanism’, Cranach, exhibition catalogue, London, 2007, pp. 52-3).
The esteem in which Cranach was already held is evident from a Latin oration delivered by the humanist Christoph Scheurl on 16 December 1508, in which he placed the artist above all his German contemporaries save Albrecht Dürer, acclaiming him as ‘the gifted, quick, consummate painter of the Saxon dukes’, worthy of ‘the first place in painting’. Such was his reputation, Scheurl declared, that ‘the Italians who usually pursue fame, proffer their hand to you, the French greet you as their master’ (H. Lüdecke, ed., Lucas Cranach der Ältere. Der Künstler und seine Zeit, Berlin, 1953, pp. 49-55; translated in Evans, ibid., p. 53). In likening Cranach to the great painters of antiquity, from Apelles to Zeuxis, he invoked only one other living artist, the Bolognese Francesco Francia, whose achievements had been praised by Scheurl’s own teacher, Filippo Beroaldo, in his commentary on Apuleius’s Metamorphoses of 1500.
It was within this humanist milieu that Cranach’s conception of Lucretia took shape, at a moment of considerable experimentation in his art. His journey to the Netherlands in 1508, in the course of which he is likely to have visited Antwerp, has prompted considerable discussion concerning the extent to which Netherlandish painting informed his subsequent work. The emergence of the female half-length figure in his early treatments of Lucretia and Salome has likewise been associated with Netherlandish pictorial conventions, although the originality of his developing artistic language resists any straightforward account of foreign influence (Friedländer and Rosenberg, op. cit., 1978, p. 21; Koepplin and Falk, op. cit., 1976, pp. 660-1). The representation of Lucretia as an intimate, half-length figure was not without precedent in contemporary Italian painting, notably in Francesco Francia’s treatment of the subject of circa 1505-6 (Dresden, Staatliche Kunstsammlungen, Gemäldegalerie), while the sensual framing of the female body by luxuriant fur and flowing hair finds a suggestive parallel in Giorgione’s Laura of 1506 (Vienna, Kunsthistorisches Museum; fig. 1). Although these affinities suggest a broader Italian pictorial context for Cranach’s invention, his familiarity with either painting remains uncertain (Evans, op. cit., p. 53). Whatever the precise sources of his invention, Cranach transformed these conventions into an idiom unmistakably his own, rejecting both the narrative elaboration and the anatomical idealisation preferred by many of his contemporaries in favour of a more intimate, psychologically suggestive image. In both Lucretia and his early representations of Salome, the drama of the subject is distilled into the commanding presence of a richly adorned female figure.
Rather than narrating the circumstances of her death, Cranach isolates the heroine against a dark, unmodulated ground, removing every indication of place and circumstance to concentrate attention upon the figure herself. Dressed in the elaborate fashion of the Saxon court, Lucretia has loosened her white gown to reveal her right breast, its richly embroidered borders and extravagantly puffed sleeves contrasting with the pale softness of her flesh. A deep green mantle envelops her left side, its luxuriant fur lining falling in long, finely articulated strands across her shoulders and lap, while a succession of heavy gold links descends from her neck. The exquisite precision with which Cranach describes these materials, from the delicately threaded pearls of her necklace to the individual curls that escape beneath her narrow headband, is matched by a remarkable tenderness in the modelling of her face. Her softly rounded features, slightly parted lips and steady outward gaze lend her an intimacy at odds with the tragic nature of the subject, while the elaborate arrangement of costume and jewellery both conceals and exposes the body, heightening the sensuality of an image ostensibly devoted to the triumph of chastity.
This conjunction of contemplation and sensuality is fundamental to Cranach’s treatment of Lucretia. Unlike Dürer, whose monumental standing Lucretia of 1518 (Munich, Alte Pinakothek; fig. 2) gives physical expression to the heroine’s fatal resolve, Cranach dispensed with the dramatic action of the suicide, presenting instead a contemplative figure whose direct engagement with the beholder invites reflection upon the meaning of her sacrifice. The Besinnlichkeit, or contemplative quality, of Cranach’s early Lucretias distinguishes them from the more energetic interpretations of the subject by his contemporaries, the violence of death giving way to a state in which its proximity and the sensuality of the female body could coexist (Koepplin and Falk, op. cit., 1976, pp. 660-1). His earliest treatments present the heroine as both ‘life-like and seductive’, possessed of an ‘acute sense of urgency’ about her tragic fate (Ainsworth, op. cit., 2022, p. 90), although in the present picture that urgency is conveyed with remarkable restraint. The dagger has barely penetrated Lucretia’s flesh, and the blood, rather than staining her breast, travels down the polished blade to gather at the guard of its gilded hilt. Executed with extraordinary delicacy, this minute detail establishes the gravity of the action while leaving the figure’s composure undisturbed. The spectator is thus confronted not with the physical horror of suicide but with an image that seems to resist the passage of time, in which beauty and death, innocence and desire are held in precarious equilibrium.
The present composition is closely related to another Lucretia, formerly in the collection of Heinz Kisters, Kreuzlingen, and subsequently in a private collection, which is dated to around 1510-13 (Friedländer and Rosenberg, op. cit., 1978, p. 78, no. 42; fig. 3). The two paintings are of comparable size and share the same essential arrangement, with the heroine presented before a dark ground, enveloped in fur and elaborate contemporary dress, the dagger raised towards her exposed breast. In the Kisters version, however, Lucretia’s hair is gathered up and both breasts are revealed, whereas in the present picture her long, loosely falling curls and the greater concealment afforded by her garments lend the figure a softer, more intimate character. Koepplin considered the Kisters painting to be the earliest surviving treatment of the subject, a dating supported by the existence of a copy bearing the monogram of Cranach’s pupil Hans Döring and the date 1514 (Koepplin and Falk, op. cit., 1976, pp. 661-2, nos. 576 and 578). The subsequent reassessment of the present panel, however, has established its priority, placing it at the beginning of this important sequence of compositions and revealing how fully Cranach had already conceived the essential characteristics of a type that would undergo numerous transformations over the following decades.
The continuing appeal of Cranach’s invention at the Saxon court is evident from a painting of Lucretia that he included among the decorations of the bridal bed of John the Steadfast and Margaret of Anhalt in 1513, described in a contemporary nuptial poem by Philipp Engelbrecht: ‘In the final place is the dishonoured Roman lady. The sword is sprayed with blood, the once starry eyes are half dimmed, Lucretia’s raiment glides from her swelling bosom’ (Lüdecke, op. cit., pp. 56 and 104-5). Cranach’s enduring engagement with the subject is further attested by the electoral accounts, which record two paintings of Lucretia in 1518, while another was presented by the court to Philipp von Solms in 1543 (W. Schade, Die Malerfamilie Cranach, Dresden, 1974, pp. 409 and 440). Yet the appeal of the subject cannot be explained by its moral associations alone, for Cranach’s treatment of Lucretia was equally suited to the tastes of Saxon courtiers who delighted in sensual representations of women. For Cranach, whose fascination with the female figure would become one of the defining features of his art, the classical heroine offered an opportunity to reconcile the exemplary virtues of antiquity with the sensuous pleasures of painting, an apparent contradiction that he made central to his conception of Lucretia.
The painting’s closest stylistic affinities are to be found not so much among Cranach’s later Lucretias, whose increasingly attenuated forms and stylised elegance reflect the development of his mature manner, as among his other female figures of the years around 1509-10. The Venus in the State Hermitage Museum, Saint Petersburg, and the Virgin and Child in the Museo Nacional Thyssen-Bornemisza, Madrid, share the present figure’s softly rounded physiognomy, delicate modelling and exceptionally sensitive treatment of hair, together with the richness of a palette in which luminous flesh is set against deep, saturated colour. Such refinement belongs to a period in which Cranach’s increasingly conscious pursuit of feminine beauty was accompanied by a growing delight in the decorative possibilities of jewellery, brocade and hair, a taste already given remarkable expression in the wings of the Martyrdom of Saint Catherine altarpiece of 1506 (London, The National Gallery; fig. 4), where the ornament is laid in with a fine, pointed brush. The same freedom and immediacy distinguish the Holy Kinship altarpiece of 1509 in Frankfurt, whose rich and abundant brushwork has nothing of the vitreous glossiness of the altarpieces painted shortly after 1510 (Friedländer and Rosenberg, op. cit., 1978, p. 21). The affinities between these sacred, mythological and historical subjects reveal the extent to which Cranach’s ideal of feminine beauty transcended their individual iconographies. Yet there is nothing formulaic in the present figure, whose expression and meticulously observed details retain an immediacy that distinguishes these early works from the more consciously mannered inventions of his later career.
The painting’s exceptionally early date has been further substantiated by technical examination undertaken before its sale in 2012 (op. cit.). The support consists of four narrow boards of limewood joined horizontally, an unusual arrangement associated with the panel-making practices employed during Cranach’s first years at Wittenberg and encountered in the wings of the Martyrdom of Saint Catherine and the Frankfurt Holy Kinship. This method appears to have been largely abandoned by around 1510-11, providing persuasive evidence for the proposed dating of the present work (see G. Heydenreich, Lucas Cranach the Elder: Painting Materials, Techniques and Workshop Practice, Amsterdam, 2007, pp. 57-8). Examination of the margins also revealed that the original framing elements had been nailed to the panel before the application of two successive white grounds, the first, more fluid preparation passing beneath the frame and the second accumulating against it to form a characteristic barbe, traces of which remain visible around the painted surface. Although infrared reflectography revealed no discernible underdrawing, the artist’s creative process is nevertheless apparent in a change to the length and positioning of Lucretia’s left thumb, which was initially conceived smaller and possibly concealed beneath the fur of her mantle. These findings, recorded following the examination of the panel and its preparation by George Bisacca, provide valuable evidence of Cranach’s working methods at this formative stage of his career (op. cit., 2012).
Despite its importance, the present painting remained comparatively little known for much of the twentieth century. Its first published reference appeared in 1932, when a seated Lucretia wearing a fur mantle and with her right shoulder exposed, then known from its appearance on the London art market in 1920, was mentioned in a discussion of a Virgin of Sorrows then in the Birnbaum collection, Amsterdam (Friedländer and Rosenberg, op. cit., 1932, p. 39, under no. 48). The painting was subsequently mentioned as a variant of the Kisters Lucretia in 1976, before being included as an autograph work in the revised catalogue of 1978, where it was dated to circa 1512-14 (Friedländer and Rosenberg, op. cit., 1978, p. 80, no. 55). Following its reappearance and examination in 2011, Werner Schade proposed a date of circa 1509, on the basis of high-resolution photographs and transparencies, while Dieter Koepplin, having examined the painting in person, suggested circa 1510, both recognising it as Cranach’s earliest surviving depiction of Lucretia (op. cit., 2012).
In the present Lucretia, the young court painter had already arrived at a conception of the female figure that was at once intensely individual and capable of almost limitless variation, transforming the moral exemplarity of an ancient heroine into an image whose appeal depended as much upon the delicacy of its execution as upon the ambiguities of its meaning. Yet what distinguishes this earliest treatment from the many that followed is the remarkable restraint with which Cranach achieves that effect. The heroine neither recoils from death nor yields entirely to the sensuality of her presentation; held between the two, she retains a gravity and inwardness that would gradually give way to the more stylised elegance of his mature art. It is in this delicate balance, between the immediacy of a living presence and the stillness of an exemplary image, that the originality of Cranach’s early invention is most fully realised.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
