Lot Essay
Jointure de boules (La Poupée) is the rarest work by Hans Bellmer to ever come to auction. A unique relief and one of only two original surviving sculptural variants—the other, La Poupée, resides in Musée nationale d’art modern centre Georges Pompidou, Paris. Bellmer’s famous doll constructions are the defining works of his career. Jointure de boules (La Poupée) was made by Bellmer for the Exposition surréaliste d'objets held at the Galerie Charles Ratton in Paris in May 1936. This landmark exhibition was the first show devoted to the Surrealist object, and alongside the present sculpture included such iconic masterpieces of the genre as Alberto Giacometti’s La Boule suspendue (1930-31), Meret Oppenheim’s Objet (Le Déjeuner en fourrure) (1936; The Museum of Modern Art, New York), Salvador Dali’s Veston aphrodisiaque (1936) and Marcel Duchamp’s Porte-bouteilles (1914).
Jointure de boules (La Poupée) is, however, more than a simple Surrealist object. A relief construction—part painting, part sculpture, part assemblage, it epitomizes Bellmer’s entire aesthetic during this crucial period when he was engrossed in exploring the concept of La Poupée. The work was made in response to repeated requests by André Breton and his circle throughout the early months of 1936 for Bellmer to contribute to their exhibition. The prior winter, the French Surrealists had been first captivated by Bellmer’s work in a copy of his small, self-published book of photographs of his doll published in 1934 and delivered to Breton by Bellmer’s young cousin Ursula. Paul Eluard immediately wrote to Bellmer about writing poems for the doll, while Breton declared to Bellmer that there was “nothing more tempting, more dangerous than the vision we owe you of [this] lost world…You are the great bearer of the Secret” (quoted in Hans Bellmer, exh. cat., Musée nationale d’art modern centre Georges Pompidou, Paris, 2006, p. 238).
Bellmer, living and working in Berlin, had made his first doll in 1933 partly in response to the Nazi assumption of power that year. Finally rejecting the authority of his tyrannical father and refusing to participate in any “useful work” that might aid the Nazi regime, he abandoned his job as a commercial artist and devoted himself to the creation of what he called an “artificial girl”—a figure that in its uncomfortable sadomasochism eloquently articulated the sinister undercurrents of the new era. Inspired by a box of toy parts he had received around this time from his mother and the emotional associations and torturous childhood memories they awoke in him, the result of Bellmer’s endeavors was a spectral puppet-like doll constructed in plaster and linen with broomstick legs (now lost). This somewhat cadaverous figure Bellmer then photographed in a variety of seductive, sinister and disturbing poses and scenarios reminiscent of a crime scene around his house. It was these that featured in his 1934 book La Poupée.
Dissatisfied with the lifelessness of this initial figure, however, in 1935, Bellmer created his second, even more provocative and disturbing doll. This version was a naked, flesh-colored figure that made use of a bizarre double-torso set around a ball joint. Bellmer had noted the use of the ball-and-socket joints used in Renaissance era dolls and mannequins at the Kaiser Friedrich Museum in Berlin and, with the help of his brother Fritz—an engineer—and his cousin Ursula, created this unforgettable doll which is now in the collection of the Musée nationale d’art modern centre Georges Pompidou in Paris. In addition to the double torso, this second doll comprised a double set of legs, and a separate torso with hair, head and arms. All linked together by ball-and-socket joints, this second iteration allowed for an even greater variety of contorted poses. He went on to document these arrangements in numerous photographs, often hand-colored in the manner of erotic photography, over the ensuing years.
Central to the appeal of Bellmer’s second, ball-jointed doll was its ability to generate visual surprises through the confusion and contortion of its different body parts: to place legs where arms should be, for example, or to substitute breasts with hip-joints and to twist its figure into a whole variety of morbid, contorted orgies of visual fascination and confusion. It was this inherent ambiguity, or what Bellmer defined as an “anagram” that, he argued, ultimately made his figure more real. Pointing to the fragments of a body, such as the truncated torso, or the ambiguous, one-eyed, leg/arm creature he created in Jointure de boules (La Poupée), Bellmer argued that such forms have a heightened realism, not just because of the anagrammatic confusion about their interchangeable components but also because of the implication such fragmentation has towards their missing parts.
In an essay written around this time, “Notes on the Subject of the Ball Joint,” Bellmer discusses this aspect of the trauma of the fragmented body, suggesting that “the body is like a sentence which invites dissection in order that its true meaning may be reconstituted in an endless series of anagrams… Since the body's overall image tends to remain intact even after actual amputations, we may surmise that the parts situated within the bounds of our modesty—the chin, the armpit, the arm—take on, in addition to their own inherent meaning, the values of the leg, the sex, and so forth, which have become available precisely through their repression. It comes down to this: the body, much like a dream, can capriciously shift the center of gravity of its images. Driven by a singular spirit of contradiction, it superimposes what it has taken from some onto others—the image of a leg, for instance, onto that of an arm, or the genitals onto the armpit—to create condensations, proofs of analogy, ambiguities, puns, and strange calculations of anatomical probability” (“Notes au sujet de la jointure à boules” in L’Anatomie de l’image, 1957 [1946], p. 38).
In addition to his second doll and Jointure de boules (La Poupée) of 1934-36, Bellmer was to make only one other doll during this crucial period. This was his now lost La mitrailleuse en état de grâce (Machine-Gunneress in a State of Grace) of 1937, a replica of which is in the collection of The Museum of Modern Art, New York. The present work is thus one of only two surviving original dolls and the only remaining in private hands.
Jointure de boules (La Poupée) is unique in Bellmer’s oeuvre as part painting, part relief, part object, part doll. Because of its clearly fragmentary nature, the work epitomizes the artist’s principle of the anagrammatic body and the Surrealists’ ideal of convulsive beauty. Comprising two baby-doll arms, bent outward at the elbows and attached at the shoulders by a ball-joint which, with the addition of a glass-eye also becomes an eyeball, the work presents a bizarre, cyclopic, squid-like homunculus apparently caught in the fishnet of a fashionable veil or hair net. Set into a picture frame against a background of faded floral wallpaper indicative of a bourgeois domestic interior, the image also appears to speak of trapped, repressed or frustrated youthful desire.
The pervasive theme of revolt against a repressive paternalistic authority or state was one common to both Bellmer and the French Surrealists. In addition, as the critic Sue Taylor has noted about Jointure de boules (La Poupée), “like the eyeball abused in Georges Bataille's infamous 1928 novella, Histoire de l'oeil (Story of the Eye), the eye in Jointure seems to peer out from between slightly parted thighs, for the doll arms also read as legs and the black net, metonymically as well as metaphorically, stands for surrounding hair” (Hans Bellmer: Anatomy of Anxiety, Cambridge, MA, 2000, pp. 128-29) In this regard, Taylor points out, Jointure de boules (La Poupée) is a work that also visually echoes the climatic, final sentence of Bellmer’s famous “Notes” on the subject of the ball-joint, which concludes with the image of a child placing monstrous flowers “in the hair of the ball joint, before it enters, in a provocative reflex of the hips and of that which it lacks, the land of external reality” (quoted in ibid., p. 218). A fusion of desire with oppression, sex with violence, sensuality with dismemberment, pleasure with trauma, Bellmer’s doll and its two variants Jointure de boules (La Poupée) and now lost La mitrailleuse en état de grâce are works that knowingly disturb and excite, allure and repel, disgust and titillate in equal measure.
Jointure de boules (La Poupée) is, however, more than a simple Surrealist object. A relief construction—part painting, part sculpture, part assemblage, it epitomizes Bellmer’s entire aesthetic during this crucial period when he was engrossed in exploring the concept of La Poupée. The work was made in response to repeated requests by André Breton and his circle throughout the early months of 1936 for Bellmer to contribute to their exhibition. The prior winter, the French Surrealists had been first captivated by Bellmer’s work in a copy of his small, self-published book of photographs of his doll published in 1934 and delivered to Breton by Bellmer’s young cousin Ursula. Paul Eluard immediately wrote to Bellmer about writing poems for the doll, while Breton declared to Bellmer that there was “nothing more tempting, more dangerous than the vision we owe you of [this] lost world…You are the great bearer of the Secret” (quoted in Hans Bellmer, exh. cat., Musée nationale d’art modern centre Georges Pompidou, Paris, 2006, p. 238).
Bellmer, living and working in Berlin, had made his first doll in 1933 partly in response to the Nazi assumption of power that year. Finally rejecting the authority of his tyrannical father and refusing to participate in any “useful work” that might aid the Nazi regime, he abandoned his job as a commercial artist and devoted himself to the creation of what he called an “artificial girl”—a figure that in its uncomfortable sadomasochism eloquently articulated the sinister undercurrents of the new era. Inspired by a box of toy parts he had received around this time from his mother and the emotional associations and torturous childhood memories they awoke in him, the result of Bellmer’s endeavors was a spectral puppet-like doll constructed in plaster and linen with broomstick legs (now lost). This somewhat cadaverous figure Bellmer then photographed in a variety of seductive, sinister and disturbing poses and scenarios reminiscent of a crime scene around his house. It was these that featured in his 1934 book La Poupée.
Dissatisfied with the lifelessness of this initial figure, however, in 1935, Bellmer created his second, even more provocative and disturbing doll. This version was a naked, flesh-colored figure that made use of a bizarre double-torso set around a ball joint. Bellmer had noted the use of the ball-and-socket joints used in Renaissance era dolls and mannequins at the Kaiser Friedrich Museum in Berlin and, with the help of his brother Fritz—an engineer—and his cousin Ursula, created this unforgettable doll which is now in the collection of the Musée nationale d’art modern centre Georges Pompidou in Paris. In addition to the double torso, this second doll comprised a double set of legs, and a separate torso with hair, head and arms. All linked together by ball-and-socket joints, this second iteration allowed for an even greater variety of contorted poses. He went on to document these arrangements in numerous photographs, often hand-colored in the manner of erotic photography, over the ensuing years.
Central to the appeal of Bellmer’s second, ball-jointed doll was its ability to generate visual surprises through the confusion and contortion of its different body parts: to place legs where arms should be, for example, or to substitute breasts with hip-joints and to twist its figure into a whole variety of morbid, contorted orgies of visual fascination and confusion. It was this inherent ambiguity, or what Bellmer defined as an “anagram” that, he argued, ultimately made his figure more real. Pointing to the fragments of a body, such as the truncated torso, or the ambiguous, one-eyed, leg/arm creature he created in Jointure de boules (La Poupée), Bellmer argued that such forms have a heightened realism, not just because of the anagrammatic confusion about their interchangeable components but also because of the implication such fragmentation has towards their missing parts.
In an essay written around this time, “Notes on the Subject of the Ball Joint,” Bellmer discusses this aspect of the trauma of the fragmented body, suggesting that “the body is like a sentence which invites dissection in order that its true meaning may be reconstituted in an endless series of anagrams… Since the body's overall image tends to remain intact even after actual amputations, we may surmise that the parts situated within the bounds of our modesty—the chin, the armpit, the arm—take on, in addition to their own inherent meaning, the values of the leg, the sex, and so forth, which have become available precisely through their repression. It comes down to this: the body, much like a dream, can capriciously shift the center of gravity of its images. Driven by a singular spirit of contradiction, it superimposes what it has taken from some onto others—the image of a leg, for instance, onto that of an arm, or the genitals onto the armpit—to create condensations, proofs of analogy, ambiguities, puns, and strange calculations of anatomical probability” (“Notes au sujet de la jointure à boules” in L’Anatomie de l’image, 1957 [1946], p. 38).
In addition to his second doll and Jointure de boules (La Poupée) of 1934-36, Bellmer was to make only one other doll during this crucial period. This was his now lost La mitrailleuse en état de grâce (Machine-Gunneress in a State of Grace) of 1937, a replica of which is in the collection of The Museum of Modern Art, New York. The present work is thus one of only two surviving original dolls and the only remaining in private hands.
Jointure de boules (La Poupée) is unique in Bellmer’s oeuvre as part painting, part relief, part object, part doll. Because of its clearly fragmentary nature, the work epitomizes the artist’s principle of the anagrammatic body and the Surrealists’ ideal of convulsive beauty. Comprising two baby-doll arms, bent outward at the elbows and attached at the shoulders by a ball-joint which, with the addition of a glass-eye also becomes an eyeball, the work presents a bizarre, cyclopic, squid-like homunculus apparently caught in the fishnet of a fashionable veil or hair net. Set into a picture frame against a background of faded floral wallpaper indicative of a bourgeois domestic interior, the image also appears to speak of trapped, repressed or frustrated youthful desire.
The pervasive theme of revolt against a repressive paternalistic authority or state was one common to both Bellmer and the French Surrealists. In addition, as the critic Sue Taylor has noted about Jointure de boules (La Poupée), “like the eyeball abused in Georges Bataille's infamous 1928 novella, Histoire de l'oeil (Story of the Eye), the eye in Jointure seems to peer out from between slightly parted thighs, for the doll arms also read as legs and the black net, metonymically as well as metaphorically, stands for surrounding hair” (Hans Bellmer: Anatomy of Anxiety, Cambridge, MA, 2000, pp. 128-29) In this regard, Taylor points out, Jointure de boules (La Poupée) is a work that also visually echoes the climatic, final sentence of Bellmer’s famous “Notes” on the subject of the ball-joint, which concludes with the image of a child placing monstrous flowers “in the hair of the ball joint, before it enters, in a provocative reflex of the hips and of that which it lacks, the land of external reality” (quoted in ibid., p. 218). A fusion of desire with oppression, sex with violence, sensuality with dismemberment, pleasure with trauma, Bellmer’s doll and its two variants Jointure de boules (La Poupée) and now lost La mitrailleuse en état de grâce are works that knowingly disturb and excite, allure and repel, disgust and titillate in equal measure.
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
.jpg?w=1)
