ALEXANDER CALDER (1898-1976)
ALEXANDER CALDER (1898-1976)
ALEXANDER CALDER (1898-1976)
3 More
ALEXANDER CALDER (1898-1976)
6 More
Herbert Lust: Collector, Scholar, Friend
ALEXANDER CALDER (1898-1976)

Untitled

Details
ALEXANDER CALDER (1898-1976)
Untitled
signed with the artist's monogram 'CA' (on the largest black element)
standing mobile—sheet metal, wire, string and paint
54 ½ x 52 x 28 ½ in. (138.4 x 132.1 x 72.4 cm.)
Executed circa 1940
Provenance
Acquired by the late owner, by April 1984.
Exhibited
New York, Pierre Matisse Gallery, Calder: Recent Work, May-June 1942.
Purchase, Neuberger Museum of Art, State University of New York, Area Codes 914⁄203: The Private Eyes – 20th Century Art from New York and Connecticut Collections, April-June 1984 (dated 1942 and titled 5 O'Clock).
Purchase, Neuberger Museum of Art, State University of New York, Crossing State Lines: 20th Century Art from Private Collections in Westchester and Fairfield Counties, March-June 1995, p. 38, no. 12 (dated 1940 and titled 5 O'Clock).
Greenwich, Bruce Museum, The Mobile, the Stabile, the Animal: Wit in the Art of Alexander Calder, September-December 1995, pp. 22 and 44 (illustrated; dated 1940).
Roslyn Harbor, Nassau County Museum of Art, Calder and Miró, June-September 1998, pp. 37 and 77 (illustrated; dated 1940).
Hartford, Wadsworth Atheneum, Calder in Connecticut, April-August 2000, pp. 70 and 165, fig. 70, no. 34 (illustrated).
Further Details
This work is registered in the archives of the Calder Foundation, New York, under application number A14961.

Brought to you by

Paige Kestenman
Paige Kestenman Vice President, Senior Specialist, Co-Head of 20th Century Evening Sale

Lot Essay

“There is a time in the lives of a few lucky artists when everything they’ve been grappling with…comes together in a singular, purified, clarified form. That’s what happened to Calder at the very beginning of the 1940s.” – Jed Perl

One of the most striking works by Alexander Calder ever to come to market, Untitled affords the viewer the ultimate opportunity to engage with the full scope of the artist’s ideas in a single work. It encapsulates Calder’s philosophy about color, movement, and form all within the confines of its striking composition. The sculpture can almost be understood as three works in one: a colorful stabile, an evocative black hanging mobile, and a vibrant “double-headed” multicolored mobile. Executed circa 1940, it dates from a pivotal period within the artist’s career when he was beginning to produce some of his most accomplished examples of his work. “Each thing I make has…a plastic quality,” Calder remarked at the time, “which includes many things—the mass, or masses; the sinuosity; the contrast of lightness to mass; the contrast of black to white; the contrast of somberness to color; whatever element of movement there is in the object, even its manner of suspension” (quoted in Pictures on Exhibit, May 1939; M. Prather, Alexander Calder 1898-1976, exh. cat., National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1998, p. 138).

On a trio of gracefully elongated legs, a tall vertical upright supports a horizontal beam. At each end of this broad support, two mobiles suspend in space. One contains a cascade of dark elements, counterbalanced by a larger single element. Its opposite—at the other end of the beam—offers a more complex arrangements of shapes and forms. The upper portion of this section of the work contains a pair of trident-like spears counterbalanced by hanging elements below. Each of the sculpture’s three principal elements rewards close examination in its own right, but together they offer up a concise appraisal of the artist’s career at this point in his life.

One of the most striking aspects of Untitled is Calder’s bold use of color. In this work he utilizes the full range of his chromatic arsenal in a highly expressive way. Black and white recur throughout Calder’s oeuvre, but they are rarely presented together in the way they are here. Red assumes a particularly commanding presence and plays an important role in the composition, and is arguably the dominant color. It was also one that lead him to declare: “I want things to be differentiated. Black and white are first—then red is next….I often wish that I had been a fauve in 1905” (quoted in K. Kuh, The Artist’s Voice, New York, 1962).

“An idea which will lead me to make a new ‘object’ may come from almost anywhere, from anything.” —ALEXANDER CALDER

Untitled was made during a pivotal period in the artist’s career. Up to this point, he had been producing works that his biographer Jed Perl has described as “rumbunctious,” but at the very beginning of the 1940s there was a marked shift to what Perl calls a “classical style.” This involved infusing his sculptures with fresh complexities and achieving effects that were emotionally deeper and more dramatic than anything that had gone before. “There is a time in the lives of a few lucky artists,” Perl continues, “when everything they’ve been grappling with…comes together in a singular, purified, clarified form. That’s what happened to Calder at the very beginning of the 1940s” (quoted in Calder. The Conquest of Time. The Early Years: 1898-1940, New York, 2017, p. 582).

By 1940 Calder had virtually abandoned the motorized kinetic sculptures that had been an important force in his art throughout much of the 1930s, preferring instead to embrace natural forces, such as air currents from an open window or the subtle breeze created by a passerby to introduce a degree of animation into his work. “An idea which will lead me to make a new ‘object’ may come from almost anywhere, from anything,” the artist has admitted (quoted in “Pictures on Exhibit,” May 1939; M. Prather, Alexander Calder 1898-1976, exh. cat., National Gallery of Art, Washington, D.C., 1998, p. 138).

At this point in his life, Calder, in his early forties, was spending more time at his home in the bucolic surrounds of Roxbury, Connecticut, and this rural setting seemed to also invigorate his imagination and nourish him in a way that had not been possible before. Not only did this period manifest in a body of work that was accomplished and sophisticated, but the discoveries he made during the early 1940s would sustain him throughout the remainder of his career. This period resulted in a number of similarly-scaled works, many of which are now housed in major institutional collections. These include Tree (1941, Calder Foundation, New York), Yucca (1941, Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum, New York), and Giraffe (1941, private collection). This interest followed a series of sculptures he made to become the setting for an Oscar Nitzchke-designed African habitat at the Bronx Zoo in 1939, a project that was never fully realized.

The grace, complexity, and visual authority of Untitled distinguish it as one of the most important sculptures from this formative moment in Calder's career. Combining the architectural presence of a stabile with the lyrical movement of a mobile, the work embodies the synthesis of opposing forces that lay at the heart of the artist's achievement. Animated by air, chance, and the viewer's own movement through space, it remains in a state of perpetual transformation. As such, Untitled stands not merely as an exceptional example of Calder's mature language, but as a compelling demonstration of the revolutionary vision that transformed sculpture in the twentieth century.


Herbert Lust: Collector, Scholar, Friend
A farm boy from Indiana who through intellect and luck became an accomplished scholar, writer, and collector, Herbert Lust, reflecting on his many achievements, described himself as “a dazed soldier of fortune, drenched with experience.” An early encounter with Keats’ “Ode to a Nightingale” propelled him toward a literary career. At the age of twenty-one, he became the youngest person ever to receive a master’s degree in philosophy and mathematics from the University of Chicago, and in 1949 he became one of the first Fulbright scholars, using his grant to spend two years in Paris investigating the influence of the American novel on French literature.

Describing his first studio visit with Alberto Giacometti, which would catalyze his collecting, Herbert Lust writes, “The space was very small, and the scattered bronzes seemed quite ugly to me. Yet my studies of philosophy and literature also told me that my initial impressions must be wrong. If Sartre and the greatest writers claimed that Alberto was a great artist, then I was just a fool, and had much to learn about art.” Giacometti was Lust’s first thrilling confrontation with contemporary art, and his initial negative response was soon replaced by a compelling desire to study and collect.

Informed by the collecting practices of Gertrude Stein, another literary hero whose legacy he knew well through his friendship with Alice B. Toklas, and using his meager Fulbright grant funds, Lust’s first major acquisition was an Yves Tanguy painting, followed in quick succession by several Hans Bellmer drawings. Tanguy’s Qui répondra? (1948), now in Lust’s collection, exemplifies Lust’s early impulse toward Surrealism, which would also lead him to assemble one of the most significant collections of Bellmer in the world.

Lust, together with his wife Virginia, whom he married in 1963, began building one of the greatest collections of Giacometti works. In 1970, the crown jewel entered the collection when Lust purchased Giacometti’s seminal Figure, demie grandeur (no. 2) from Joseph R. Shapiro, a prominent Chicago collector and founding president of the city’s Museum of Contemporary Art. “It was the first and fullest recognizable portrait done in Giacometti’s greatest period,” writes Lust. “It was in homage to his great love, Isabel Delmer, whom he had sculpted off and on for a dozen years by 1949. He was fascinated by her chignon. In no bronze does Alberto depict better a man’s love for a woman. She is love, tenderness, courage and majesty incarnate, a weightless queen in an invisible kingdom.”

Lust’s collection expanded well beyond the European avant-garde. Three years after acquiring Figure, demie grandeur (no. 2), another stroke of luck found him at a society gathering in New York hosted by the du Pont family. There he met Robert Indiana, who immediately challenged Lust’s predilection for European art and his reluctance to collect contemporary American artists. What began as a spirited debate evolved into a decades-long engagement with Indiana’s work. Lust ultimately acquired more than thirty works by the artist, including important examples such as FOUR (1965) and LOVE (1975). The artist’s LUST FAMILY PORTRAIT (1995), inscribed “For Virginia and Herbert Lust,” remains a testament to their enduring relationship.

Virginia Lust Gallery, with which Herbert was closely involved, championed other important artists as well, including Frank Stella. Lust eventually acquired Stella’s early masterpiece Les Indes Galantes (1964), from the artist’s seminal Mitered Maze series. Titled after Jean- Philippe Rameau’s Baroque opera-ballet concerning Cupid’s search for love across the globe, and inspired by Stella’s time in Paris, the work chimes compellingly with Lust’s own personal journey.

Through careful scholarship, insightful writing, and deep friendships, Herbert Lust built one of the greatest collections of contemporary art of his generation. Armed with luck and a sharp intellect, Lust built an incredible collection of artists whom he knew both personally and academically. His success in both business and collecting allowed him to generously support numerous institutions—his gifts of hundreds of works from his collection to the Tel Aviv Museum and to the Hirshhorn Museum and Sculpture Garden proved transformative to both museums, expanding the scope and reach of their collections. Holding seminal works by artists ranging from Giacometti and Calder, Tanguy, Bellmer, and Bauermeister, to Frank Stella and Robert Indiana, Herbert Lust’s collection explores in depth the artists he befriended. At once perceptively scholarly and deeply personal, the collection tells the story of both an exceptional personality and the course of art history across the twentieth century.

More from 20th Century Evening Sale

View All
View All