3 More
PROPERTY OF A GENTLEMAN
NICOLAS TOURNIER (MONTBÉLIARD 1590-1639 TOULOUSE)

The Denial of Saint Peter

Details
NICOLAS TOURNIER (MONTBÉLIARD 1590-1639 TOULOUSE)
The Denial of Saint Peter
oil on canvas
57 x 79 ¾ in. (144.6 x 202.5 cm)
Provenance
(Possibly) with Dr Robert Bragge (1700-1777), United Kingdom; Prestage, London, 15 February 1750 (=1st day), lot 79, as 'Valientini', where acquired for 18 gns. by,
Peregrine Bertie, 3rd Duke of Ancaster (1714-1778), Grimsthorpe Castle, Lincolnshire.
(Possibly) Samuel Archbutt, Esq., United Kingdom; his sale, Phillips, London, 11 May 1848, lot 86, as 'Valentino, Saint Peter denying Christ'.
Bruno Rampini, Honorary Consul of Honduras in Florence, until 1965, from whom acquired via Nino Salocchi, Florence, by the following,
Private aristocratic collection, Florence, and by descent, from whom acquired by the present owner.
Literature
(Possibly) G. Redford, Art Sales: A History of Sales of Pictures and Other Works of Art, II, London, 1888, p. 259.
A. Brejon de Lavergnée, 'Pour Nicolas Tournier sur son séjour romain', Paragone, XXV, no. 287, January 1974, p. 54, note 35.
B. Nicolson, The International Caravaggesque Movement: Lists of Pictures by Caravaggio and His Followers throughout Europe from 1590 to 1650, Oxford, 1979, p. 102.
C. Wright, The French Painters of the Seventeenth Century, London, 1985, p. 266.
B. Nicolson, Caravaggism in Europe, 2nd ed., revised and enlarged by L. Vertova, Turin, 1990, I, p. 198.
A. Hémery, ed., Nicolas Tournier 1590–1639: Un peintre caravagesque, exhibition catalogue, Toulouse, 2001, pp. 10, 96 and 175, under no. 8, where cited by A. Brejon de Lavergnée as one of four versions long recorded as autograph, and listed by Hémery under ‘Œuvres rejetées du catalogue’ as a work recorded by Nicolson (op. cit) in the Nino Salocchi collection in 1965.
The present picture will be included in Axel Hémery’s forthcoming catalogue raisonné of Nicolas Tournier’s work.
Sale room notice
Please refer to the online cataloguing for updated literature.

Brought to you by

Maja Markovic
Maja Markovic Director, Head of Evening Sale

Lot Essay

The rediscovery of this monumental Denial of Saint Peter brings to light a major work from Nicolas Tournier's Roman years, illuminating a formative moment in the development of one of the most distinctive artistic personalities among the French followers of Caravaggio. Though profoundly indebted to the pictorial inventions of Bartolomeo Manfredi, the composition already displays the remarkable stillness and introspection that distinguish Tournier's mature work. The drama unfolds among five monumental figures, whose gestures convey the immediacy of the accusation, yet whose expressions suggest a curious detachment from the event. In this tension between action and contemplation, Tournier began to transform the familiar conventions of Caravaggesque painting into an artistic language of his own.

Born into a family of painters in Montbéliard in 1590, Tournier probably received his earliest training from his father, André, before travelling to Italy. Although previously documented in Rome only from 1619, recent archival research has established his presence there by 1616 at the latest: on 5 January 1617, 'after being instructed in the faith', he abjured Protestantism before Pope Paul V in the office of the Roman Inquisition (P. Cavazzini, 'Success and Failure in a Violent City: Bartolomeo Manfredi, Nicolas Tournier, and Valentin de Boulogne', in A. Lemoine and K. Christiansen, eds., Valentin de Boulogne: Beyond Caravaggio, exhibition catalogue, New York, 2016, p. 21). It was in Rome that Tournier came under the influence of Manfredi, whose workshop, an important centre for the dissemination of Caravaggio's innovations, has traditionally been regarded as the setting for Tournier's artistic formation. While such an apprenticeship has generally been accepted, Cavazzini has demonstrated that, although Manfredi maintained a flourishing workshop with assistants and paying pupils, no document places Tournier in it. He was nevertheless living close to Manfredi's former residence in 1619, and the loss of the registers of San Lorenzo in Lucina for 1616-18 makes it impossible to say whether he had earlier lived a few doors from the painter, or even in his house (op. cit., 2001, p. 22; N. Hartje, 'L'influence de Bartolomeo Manfredi (1582-1622) sur les caravagesques français et sur Nicolas Tournier en particulier', ibid., pp. 29-30; Cavazzini, op. cit., 2016, pp. 21-2).

The present picture finds its most immediate compositional antecedent in Manfredi's Denial of Saint Peter of circa 1618 (Braunschweig, Herzog Anton Ulrich-Museum; fig. 1), which places the biblical episode in a guardroom, where soldiers gather around a table absorbed in a game of chance. Manfredi's treatment was itself indebted to Jusepe de Ribera's earlier Denial of circa 1615 in Palazzo Corsini, Rome, which had united the accusation of Peter with a scene of gambling that made it the decisive prototype in Rome, adopted in turn by Manfredi, Honthorst, Valentin de Boulogne and Tournier himself (G. Papi, 'Valentin and His Artistic Formation in Rome', in Lemoine and Christiansen, op. cit., 2016, pp. 36-7). The game of dice may also allude to the soldiers casting lots for Christ's garments at the Crucifixion, lending a further significance to an episode ostensibly incidental to the narrative (Christiansen, ibid., p. 118). Tournier retained this juxtaposition of sacred and profane subjects, arranging his protagonists in a shallow, frieze-like composition, with Peter standing apart at the left and the soldiers occupying the centre and right. The emphatic gesture of the bearded soldier in the plumed hat, whose outstretched arm directs the accusation towards the apostle, connects the two episodes, yet the figures remain curiously independent of one another. Peter turns away, raising his hand in denial, while the maidservant watches him intently; beside them, a helmeted soldier rests his head upon his hand, seemingly indifferent to the unfolding drama, as his companion leans over the carved antique altar that serves as a table, a motif taken directly from Manfredi. Their physical proximity contrasts with the restraint of their psychological interaction, a characteristic that would become central to Tournier's art.

While the composition is unmistakably Manfredian, the figures themselves reveal an increasingly independent artistic imagination. The bearded soldier in the plumed hat belongs to a distinctive repertoire of types that Tournier employed repeatedly throughout his career, notably in the Drinker Raising his Glass in the Galleria Estense, Modena, and the two paintings of a Soldat, one in the Musée des Augustins, Toulouse, and the other, a small copper, formerly in a Parisian private collection (Hémery, op. cit., 2001, pp. 82-5 and 126-30, nos. 2, 22 and 23). Hémery traced the origins of this familiar physiognomy, with its furrowed brow, wide eyes and carefully trimmed beard and moustache, to the Modena picture, executed during Tournier's earliest Roman period, observing its recurrence in subsequent religious and secular compositions (ibid., p. 128). Equally significant is the figure of Saint Peter, whose features Hémery had already compared with those of the apostle in the Denial formerly with Colnaghi and of Christ in Christ Blessing the Children in Palazzo Corsini, Rome, a comparison in which he expressly included the present painting, then known to him only at second hand (ibid., p. 96, nos. 8 and 19). Adapted across religious and secular subjects, these recurring figures reveal the individual pictorial repertoire that Tournier developed from the conventions of his Roman training.

Tournier's distinctive economy of means is evident in the broad passages of warm ochre that define Peter's mantle, while the sweeping folds of the maidservant's white drapery and the vivid reds of the soldier's sleeves contrast with the sharply illuminated reflections of the armour. The relative breadth of these passages is balanced by a more precise treatment of the faces and the delicate highlights of the soldier's feather. Such vigorous handling is characteristic of Tournier's technique, as established by scientific examination of other paintings, although it was by no means confined to his early career (É. Martin, 'À propos de la pratique picturale de Nicolas Tournier', in Hémery, op. cit., 2001, pp. 71-5; C. Gargam, 'Quelques remarques sur les photographies scientifiques', ibid., pp. 76-8). More revealing is the comparatively rigid construction of the figures and their placement within a shallow pictorial space. Hémery identified the construction of space as the central challenge of Tournier's early independent years, and read the pictures of this moment as so many stages in the conquest of a solidly built pictorial space (op. cit., 2001, pp. 22-4). The present work would seem to belong to this formative period, perhaps around 1621-23, when Tournier was beginning to establish his independence from Manfredi, and it falls within the intermediate Roman period of 1620-25 in which Hémery grouped the pictures most directly dependent upon the Braunschweig Denial (ibid., p. 100). Its relatively straightforward organisation contrasts with the increasingly elaborate compositions of the Denials in the High Museum of Art, Atlanta and the Museo Nacional del Prado, Madrid, the latter dated by Hémery to circa 1625-26, in which a greater number of figures are integrated into more complex spatial arrangements (ibid., pp. 104-6 and 110-12). In that conquest lies the origin of Tournier's mature manner, the rigidity of his figures and his difficulties with spatial construction resolving themselves in time into the stillness, monumental simplicity and introspection that distinguish his later painting.

In his reconstruction of the sequence, Hémery placed the version formerly with Colnaghi among the artist's earliest treatments, one of his first thoughts on the theme and the only one in which Saint Peter is seated, followed by the painting in the Gemäldegalerie Alte Meister, Dresden (circa 1622-25), and the more ambitious compositions in Atlanta (circa 1624-25, although now dated by the museum to circa 1630) and Madrid (circa 1625-26). The subject continued to occupy Tournier after his return to France, as demonstrated by a smaller, three-figure version (formerly Walpole Gallery, London; sold Christie's, New York, 31 January 1997, lot 92), which Hémery dated to after 1630 and regarded as a Languedoc interpretation of the theme, deliberately daylit and stripped of descriptive detail (ibid., pp. 94-8, 104-6, 110-12, 134 and 136). The rediscovery of the present picture has, however, led Hémery to reconsider the sequence he had previously established, raising anew the question of its place within Tournier's development (private communication).

The picture was first recognised by Roberto Longhi in 1965, when he identified Tournier as its most plausible author, noting its close relationship with the circle of Manfredi (letter to the then owner, 30 March 1965). It was previously regarded as a work by Valentin de Boulogne, according to the inscription adorning its frame, and may have been sold as such in 1750 and again in 1848, which would have been understandable given the close artistic affinities between Tournier and Valentin, whose works were frequently confused, particularly their respective treatments of the Denial of Saint Peter. Indeed, the Prado picture was catalogued as Valentin until 1973 and the Atlanta canvas was still sold as one in 1962. Although the present picture was subsequently recorded as Tournier by Benedict Nicolson, who had seen the painting in 1965, and mentioned by Hémery in his discussion of the formerly Colnaghi Denial, it remained effectively unknown to modern scholarship, having never been illustrated in the literature and surviving in the visual record only through a photograph preserved in the Longhi archive (Nicolson, op. cit., 1990, p. 198; Hémery, op. cit., 2001, pp. 96 and 175). Whatever its eventual place within that sequence, its rediscovery restores an important work to Tournier’s Roman oeuvre, offering fresh insight into the development of the artistic vision that would distinguish his mature painting.

We are grateful to Axel Hémery for confirming the attribution on the basis of photographs (private communication). The painting will be included in his forthcoming catalogue raisonné of the artist's work.

More from Old Masters Evening Sale

View All
View All